…Debt to equity swap: A viable option for Ghana’s debt restructuring
Ghana, like many developing countries, has been facing the challenge of debt sustainability and servicing its debt obligations. The government has recently defaulted on its debt obligations and has launched a domestic debt exchange programme in an effort to address the problem. With limited options available for financing the swaps of public foreign debt, one possibility that has emerged is for the government to sell its public enterprises in exchange for debt. Debt restructuring can have several negative effects on individual bondholders and pensioners, including reduced returns on their investments, increased risk associated with the new debt instrument, and decreased confidence in the government’s ability to meet its obligations. These effects can be particularly damaging for pensioners, who rely on their investments to support their retirement and healthcare. This article will explore the concept of debt-to-equity swap, its potential benefits and drawbacks, and provide recommendations for the Ghanaian Government to consider as it seeks to restructure its debt.
What is debt to equity swap?
A debt-to-equity swap is a financial transaction in which a borrower exchanges debt for equity in a company. In the case of a government, this would mean exchanging its debt obligations for equity in public enterprises. This approach allows the government to reduce its debt obligations and reduce the risk of default while still retaining part ownership of the enterprise.
Non-performing SOEs
In Ghana, many state-owned enterprises (SOEs) have struggled with poor corporate governance and ineffective management, leading to losses that have become a burden on government finances. This has been exacerbated by excessive political influence, which has prevented these SOEs from operating effectively and efficiently. Given this context, it is important for the government to consider alternative financing options that can help to address these issues, and support the development of the economy.
One such option is to list SOEs on the stock market and use a special purpose vehicle (SPV) for debt-to-equity swap in the government’s debt restructure programme. Debt-to-equity swap has been used by several countries as a means of domestic debt restructuring, and has produced several positive outcomes for their economies. Here are a few examples:
- Russia: In the late 1990s, Russia used debt-to-equity swap as part of its domestic debt restructuring programme. This allowed the government to convert debt into equity, which helped to reduce the burden of debt on the government’s finances. The swap also helped to promote the development of the capital market and attract foreign investment, which has supported the growth of the economy over the long term.
- Argentina: In 2005, Argentina used debt-to-equity swap as part of its domestic debt restructuring programme. This allowed the government to reduce its debt burden and improve its financial position, which helped to support the growth of the economy. The swap also helped to attract foreign investment and improve the stability of the financial sector, which has had a positive impact on the economy over the long term.
- Turkey: In the late 2000s, Turkey used debt-to-equity swap as part of its domestic debt restructuring programme. This allowed the government to convert debt into equity, which reduced the burden of debt on the government’s finances and improved its financial position. The swap also helped to attract foreign investment and improve the stability of the financial sector, which has supported the growth of the economy over the long term.
This approach has the potential to bring several benefits to Ghana, including:
- Banks and insurance companies: Banks and insurance companies hold a significant amount of debt in Ghana, and the burden of debt restructuring can have a negative impact on their financial performance and stability. By converting debt into equity, banks and insurance companies can reduce the risk associated with the debt as they will now have a stake in the performance of the SOEs. This can help to improve their financial position and support their continued growth and development.
- Financial sector: The financial sector as a whole can benefit from debt-to-equity swap by reducing the overall risk associated with debt and improving the stability of the sector. This can help to promote the development of the capital market and increase investment opportunities, which can support the growth of the economy and contribute to the development of the financial sector.
- Individual bondholders: Individual bondholders can also benefit from debt-to-equity swap, as it can provide them with a stake in the performance of the SOEs. This can reduce the risk associated with their investment and improve the returns they receive as they will now be able to share in the profits of these enterprises and also benefit from capital gains. Those who want immediate liquidity to meet personal expenses can sell off their interest to raise funds.
- Improved corporate governance: Listing SOEs on the stock market can help to improve corporate governance by bringing in new investors and increasing accountability. This can lead to better decision-making and improved performance of these enterprises, which can increase the value of these enterprises and contribute to the development of the capital market for long-term funding.
- Better management: By creating a special purpose vehicle to manage the debt-to-equity swap, the government can ensure that the swap is structured in a way that is in the best interest of the government and the people of Ghana. This can help to reduce the influence of politics on these SOEs, which can lead to improved management and better outcomes.
- Increased access to capital: Listing SOEs on the stock market can provide the government with access to capital that can be used to finance other development projects. This can support the growth of the economy and help to achieve other development goals.
- Reduced burden on government finances: By using a debt-to-equity swap, the government can reduce the burden on its finances by converting debt into equity. This can help to reduce the interest burden and improve the government’s financial position, allowing it to allocate more resources to other development projects.
- Improved credit rating: A reduction in debt can lead to an improvement in the credit rating of the government. This can result in lower interest rates on future borrowing, making it easier and cheaper for the government to access credit in the future.
Drawbacks of debt-to-equity swap
Loss of control: One of the main drawbacks of a debt-to-equity swap is the loss of control over the public enterprise. This can result in the government losing influence over the direction and operations of the enterprise.
Reduced revenues: By exchanging debt for equity, the government can reduce its revenues from the public enterprise. This can result in a decrease in resources available for public spending.
Political opposition: There may be political opposition to the sale of public enterprises, especially if the government is seen as selling off national assets.
Recommendations for the Ghanaian Government
Conduct a thorough analysis: The government should conduct a thorough analysis of its debt situation and the potential benefits and drawbacks of a debt-to-equity swap. This analysis should take into account the impact on the government’s financial position, the operations of public enterprises, and the views of stakeholders.
Involve stakeholders: The government should involve stakeholders, such as employees, unions, and the public, in the process of considering a debt-to-equity swap. This will ensure that their views are taken into account, and that they are aware of the impact of the swap on their interests.
Ensure transparency: The government should ensure that the process of a debt-to-equity swap is transparent, and that the terms of the exchange are fair and equitable. This will help to build public trust in the government and increase the chances of success for the swap.
Develop a clear implementation plan: The government should develop a clear implementation plan that outlines the steps that need to be taken to complete the swap, including the selection of public enterprises to be sold, the valuation process, and the distribution of equity. This plan should be communicated clearly to all stakeholders to ensure their understanding and support.
Seek Professional Advice: The government should seek professional advice from financial experts, lawyers and other specialists to ensure that the swap is structured in a way that is in the best interests of the government and the people of Ghana.
Conclusion
Debt to equity swap is a complex financial transaction that should not be taken lightly. The Ghanaian Government must consider the potential benefits and drawbacks of this approach carefully and seek professional advice to ensure that it is structured in a way that is in the best interests of the government and the people of Ghana. By involving stakeholders, ensuring transparency, and developing a clear implementation plan, the government can increase the chances of success for the swap, and help to build public trust in the process.
Debt to equity swap can have long-term benefits for the development and growth of Ghana’s economy and capital market. In particular, it can contribute to the deepening of the capital market and increase its liquidity.
Deepening of capital market: By bringing in private investors, a debt-to-equity swap can help to deepen the capital market by increasing the number of participants and improving market efficiency. This can lead to more investment opportunities and a more diverse range of assets available for investment, which can help to improve the overall health of the market.
Increased liquidity: The increased participation in the capital market can lead to increased liquidity as more buyers and sellers enter the market. This can make it easier for investors to buy and sell assets, which can help to improve market efficiency and reduce volatility.
Improved capital formation: The capital raised from a debt-to-equity swap can be used to finance the growth and development of public enterprises, which can lead to increased capital formation in the economy. This can support the development of new businesses, create jobs, and increase economic activity, which can contribute to long-term growth and development.
Better corporate governance: Improved corporate governance can also lead to better decision-making and improved performance of public enterprises, which can increase the value of these enterprises and contribute to the development of the capital market.
Better access to capital: The sale of public enterprises in exchange for debt can also provide the government with access to capital that can be used to finance other development projects. This can support the growth of the economy and help to achieve other development goals.
In conclusion, a debt-to-equity swap has the potential to bring long-term benefits to Ghana’s development and capital market by deepening the market, increasing liquidity, improving capital formation, and supporting better corporate governance and access to capital. The government must carefully consider the potential benefits and drawbacks of this approach and seek professional advice to ensure that it is structured in a way that is in the best interest of the government, investors and the people of Ghana.
The writer is an Economic Policy & Financial Analyst
Cell: +233265560612/+233271405700
