Women are self-selecting out of the African credit market
As a girl, I was taught to believe that personal agency prevails over societal biases. I was told that I could accomplish anything if I believed in myself and that sexism was not insurmountable. Later, as a woman, I found out that my parents’ advice could not have been wiser. In Africa, the gender gap in access to financial services is driven by women entrepreneurs’ own self-perception. Such perception leaves many African women on the fringes of the financial sector—unable to save, borrow, or build capital.
Worldwide, women’s access to finance is disproportionately low. Despite substantial overall progress – in 2017, the World Bank reported, 1.2 billion more people had bank accounts than in 2011 – there is still a 9 percent gap between women’s and men’s access. In sub-Saharan Africa, only 37 percent of women have a bank account compared with 48 percent of men, a gap that has only widened over the past several years. The figures are even worse in North Africa, where about two-thirds of the adult population remains unbanked and the gender gap for access to finance is 18 percent – the largest in the world.
These striking figures raise urgent questions for decision-makers in Africa. What continues to fuel gender disparity in access to finance across the continent? And why, despite all efforts, is the gap even wider today than a decade ago?
The mainstream view of economists is that supply-side constraints, such as high interest rates and collateral requirements, play a major role in excluding women from the formal credit market. Credit rationing through high interest rates disproportionately discourages women entrepreneurs from applying for loans, while lack of collateral can mean they have less access to loans than their male counterparts (Morsy and Youssef 2017). And when they do have access, women typically face more stringent loan arrangements than men.
Overemphasis on the credit market’s supply side by academics, policymakers, and practitioners means that demand-side factors and their influence on the gender gap in access to finance have been largely overlooked, especially in Africa. But women’s decision-making behaviour also plays a key role in this gender gap.
In the credit market, women entrepreneurs fail even to apply for loans because of such factors as low financial literacy, risk aversion, and fear of failure. Intuitively, one would expect women who choose to be entrepreneurs to be at least as competitive as men entrepreneurs. Why, then, are they self-selecting out of the credit market?
Fresh evidence drawn from the credit markets of 47 African countries suggests that women entrepreneurs in Africa in general, and North Africa in particular, are more likely to self-select out of the credit market because of low perceived creditworthiness. These women did not apply for loans or lines of credit because they were discouraged by their own perception that their applications would be denied. Our study finds that women managers of micro and small firms are more likely than men to self-select out of the credit market.
Along with this key finding, we observed three stunning phenomena which reinforce our ‘demand-side’ hypothesis. First, the complexity of application procedures and unfavourable loan and credit terms did not discourage women entrepreneurs from applying for credit. Second, women entrepreneurs’ self-selection was not found to relate to the observed creditworthiness of their firms. And, finally, women’s self-selection persisted even in the absence of discriminatory lending practices – suggesting that this behaviour is not merely a response to discrimination by financial institutions.
Such evidence presents an opportunity to close the persistent gender gap for access to finance in Africa and presumably other developing regions too. African decision-makers should, can, and must do more to address demand-side factors: such as the financial literacy of women and girls. This is indispensable in today’s rapidly changing and complex credit market. Even in a country like Kenya, which has a sound financial system and many women-specific programmes, women entrepreneurs still face numerous demand-side challenges to accessing those funds. Financially-literate entrepreneurs make more informed financial decisions overall and assess their creditworthiness more objectively. Hence, arming women entrepreneurs with the appropriate financial knowledge and skills will boost their effective engagement in the credit market.
One pioneer model is Malaysia’s Women Entrepreneur Financing Programme, which equips women with the knowledge and skills needed to enhance their strategic business ability in key functional areas, including financial management, marketing, leadership, and technology. The programme has helped close Malaysia’s gender gap in borrowing.
Another gender empowerment vehicle is the African Development Bank’s Affirmative Finance Action for Women in Africa (AFAWA) programme, which facilitates women’s access to finance via an innovative risk-sharing mechanism. AFAWA offers capacity building services for women entrepreneurs and advocates for reforms to support women-owned businesses. Last year, G7 leaders pledged US$251million to back the programme aimed at unlocking US$3billion in private sector funding.
Differing financial behaviour
In addition to financial knowledge, gender differences extend to financial behaviour. Women, for example, are more likely than men to save informally. One way to foster women’s demand for financial services is, thus, to introduce financial products aimed at meeting the needs of borrowers who traditionally use informal systems of finance – for example, loans that accept smaller and more movable assets and traditional wealth storage mediums such as livestock and gold as collateral. Governments can help develop such new products—for instance, by putting in place the necessary legal and regulatory framework.
Some local banks in the West Bank and Gaza now offer loans to small and medium-sized enterprises based on movable assets, with a wide range of innovative products for women, including collateral-free loans and loans secured by gold. These loans are accompanied by financial literacy programmes and online business toolkits and advisory services to help smaller enterprises and women entrepreneurs manage and grow their businesses.
Our research shows that it is mainly demand-side factors which limit access to finance for African women entrepreneurs, especially in northern Africa. We controlled for differences between men and women entrepreneurs in terms of talent and the characteristics of their respective firms. We ruled out discrimination in the supply of credit or institutional barriers as driving the observed self-selection. Our conclusion: men and women behave differently. These behavioural differences are based on different risk, social, and competitive preferences.
Africa’s gender gap in access to finance can have a dramatic impact on social and economic progress. Women today dominate African agriculture, the continent’s most important sector. When women farmers lack access to financial services, their ability to invest in modern technologies to raise their productivity is limited. They cannot diversify their farms. They cannot grow high-value crops and invest in assets such as livestock. And they cannot invest in better nutrition for their children.
The fashion industry in sub-Saharan Africa is also dominated by women, whose small businesses connect a vibrant cotton-textile-garment industry that produces a whopping US$31billion annually. Without access to financing, women-owned enterprises and entrepreneurs struggle to tap into higher-value areas of the fashion industry.
With greater access to finance working capital, many African women entrepreneurs will see their businesses blossom, paving the road toward a better future for everyone.
HANAN MORSY is the director of the macroeconomic policy and research department at the African Development Bank Group.
This article is based on African Development Bank Working Paper 317, ‘Women Self-Selection out of the Credit Market in Africa,’ by Hanan Morsy, Amira El-Shal, and Andinet Woldemichael.
Demirgüç-Kunt, A., L. Klapper, D. Singer, S. Ansar, and J. Hess. 2018. The Global Findex Database 2017: Measuring Financial Inclusion and the Fintech Revolution. Washington, DC: World Bank.
Morsy, H., and H. Youssef. 2017.“Access to Finance—Mind the Gender Gap.” EBRD Working Paper 202, European Bank for Reconstruction and Development, London
Credit: Finance & Development, March 2020, Vol. 57, No. 1